Everyone's a Critic

Last night, my friend Kathy called me to tell me that her mate of 25 years, my college roommate and best friend Barb, was inching closer to death.

What started off as a back-ache was eventually diagnosed as bladder cancer. It then metastasized, and spread to internal organs, affecting her kidneys. She went from a 75% chance of surviving the next five years (if her bladder was removed), to a 5% chance. It was inoperable, and the only treatment they could do was chemo, which would only shrink the tumor enough for other symptoms to be suppressed. She would ultimately never be "cured" of the cancer.

At that point, I adopted a motto of, "we won't know until we know." Obviously the odds were against her, but...somebody has to be in the 5%, so...who knows? 

In my head, my "math" (completely unscientific and involving no math whatsoever) told me she would not be around to see the next presidential election. I thought, that's long enough for all of us who love her to make sure she knows that we do. It's far from a good scenario, but...how many of us die without having that time to connect with the ones we care about?

Yesterday, they discovered that the cancer had expanded again, this time to her stomach. In addition, there was a small perforation in her small intestine which would make chemotherapy impossible.

I feel like...now we know.

Now we know that she would never catch that much-needed break, medically. Since the cancer was discovered, there has been virtually no good news on that front.

Now is the time when you feel the full brunt of the natural human emotion surrounding death--when you are in the inner circle of a person who is dying. Now is the time when reality strikes and people start to freak out a little.

As normal as it is to freak out, it's never been my reaction. 

That's another thing people freak out about.

Ironically, Barb worked in a funeral home right up until she had to stop working. She saw it all the time. She'd say death makes living people crazy--all those questions, from who will pay for the funeral, what will happen at the service, etc. The living feel like they have to duke it out to get what they want out of the deal, and they mostly ignore the wishes of the dead, even if the dead person wrote them down and made them all swear to follow their wishes. As soon as a person dies, it all goes out the window.

Case in point: My husband Jim's father died while we were dating. James Sr, ("Doug" to all of us) had been vocal about his wishes, and had them witnessed and signed. He wanted to be cremated and have his ashes put in the briefcase that he carried for the 40 years he worked in an office. 

How many of his wishes were carried out by his next of kin (his 2nd wife, who was not the mother of his children)? 

Zero. Exactly zero.

His wife and Jim's sister said they wouldn't cremate Doug because he was Catholic and they thought that whole briefcase idea was ridiculous. Jim was pissed off, and, rightfully so. They went against what his father had wanted, but...who was going to stop them? Doug was no longer there to have a say in the matter.

12 years later, Jim died, and basically the same thing happened. I was no longer married to him at the time, so I didn't have a say, and don't envy his daughter having to plan a funeral when she herself wasn't even 25 years old yet, but...that funeral didn't feel like the Jim I knew. 

I think it's rare to have a service that feels like the person you are honoring--maybe it's because we are all a little different to each person we meet. Parents put together a different service than a person's friend might, for example. We know people in different ways and what feels like honoring them to one person, feels tone deaf to another.

When my father passed away, our local small town pastor was left with the task of eulogizing him. Let me start by saying that Don Carr was not a man who attended church. Not a regular Sunday-goer, not an Easter/Christmas goer...just...didn't go. He didn't know Pastor Wayne, and Pastor Wayne didn't really know him. We sat around at the family service with Pastor Wayne at the front of the room, asking us to tell him about my dad. We did. We all had stories. Some of them seemed like they were out of a Smokey and the Bandit movie because that was who my father was, ultimately--a bit of The Bandit with a heaping handful of Rooster Cogburn thrown in there. Cowboy hat, crooked smile, charming as hell, good at what he did, and not interested in your bullshit. (We went to see True Grit on the big screen the other day, and...that's my dad, right there. John Wayne = Don Carr).

The pastor fashioned a decent eulogy for the funeral based on the things we told him at the family service, but the mischievousness was missing, for me. Of course it was missing--the head mischief maker was being uncharacteristically quiet in the box at the front of the room, instead of hanging with us in the pews. He was not a pew sitter to begin with, so I suppose that part is perfectly appropriate.

Maybe the reason I don't like funerals is because they never feel like they should, to me.

*sigh* Everyone's a critic, right?

**Cue flashback to the TV Show Six Feet Under, "Invisible Woman" episode--the single lady, at home with her cat(s), chokes to death on one of those frozen, microwave, "meals for one" in the opening scene. Her body is not found for a while, and, it's not pretty, so they can't do much with it. At her funeral, pre-planned and paid for by the deceased, we hear a recording of Jennifer Holliday belting out "And I'm Telling You I'm Not Going" to a room full of empty pews. Wow...that's...unexpected, but...it's what she wanted, and who knew her better than she, herself? None of the people on her contact list were involved in the planning or even showed up to the funeral. If her friends had gotten involved, I'm sure that song would have gone the way of the Doug's briefcase.**

(I fully expect that Barb's funeral will go like this: Her father, with the money, will make all the decisions and all the speeches, and, like all the decisions he has made "for" her for most of her 55 years, those decisions will have nothing to do with what Barb wants, and will exclude Kathy, entirely.

Mark my words. I am making this prediction, right now, and I'll bet $100 on it to any taker, though I would be happier to lose that bet than win it. Barb wants to be cremated and to have Kathy keep her cremains. My $100 says he'll do a traditional burial in her home town, 250 miles away from Kathy. 

I better be wrong, or that man is going straight to hell.)

At my age, I have been able to avoid going to many funerals. I suppose that will start to change, now, as time ticks on. My mother is nearly 80 and goes to a lot of funerals, unfortunately. If luck holds, I will one day be almost 80 and going to a lot of funerals, too, even though I hate them. They say funerals are for the living, and that is certainly true in that the dead are no longer here to talk about what this whole "life" thing meant to them. If only they could--maybe that would set a few people straight. 

I'm sure somebody would still walk out of the room disappointed.

I have, at this hour, which is less than 24 hours since I heard my best friend's death is imminent, already been told that I'm doing this whole "mourning" thing wrong.

Everyone's a critic.

I am easing into the idea of her not being here anymore. At some point, I'll hit a bump, and have a sob. 

I will probably hit several bumps and have several sobs.

I have a lot of complicated feelings about this that will never be spoken beyond one or two extremely trusted acquaintances. The online community is never going to see me cry. This is not for your consumption.

No wailing or gnashing of teeth. No bedside vigil. I will see her and let her speak her peace, but I will never, ever, speak mine to her. I don't have the right.

I will think of her when I travel, and think of her every time I see The Wizard of Oz, or Gone With The Wind, or Jaws. I do that now, and it won't change when she is gone. I will think of her when Robert and I are sitting at breakfast at Curran's, if I can bring myself to ever have breakfast at Curran's again, since she can't join us there. I will think of her when I'm rummaging through tchotchke shops, or any time I hear Huey Lewis...just like I do now.

These are rather specific ways of mourning and honoring a person and none of them are "wrong", but this is how it comes to pass that funerals are so...unsatisfying. We think of them as a way to say goodbye, and there just *isn't* a way. That person is forever. They live on, long past the time their body is disposed of. There is no "end", no finale. They are there in that song or that movie or that little Tin Man knick-knack you found at that junk shop...until you yourself die and take your memories with you.

We know this, but....we forget, and, we freak out because it all seems so urgent now, and we want to duke it out with people to make sure *our* way of mourning comes out on top.

There is no "timely" death, no "proper" way to mourn, no by-the-book sadness, and there will probably never be a fully satisfying funeral. It is my hope that this transition will be a peaceful one, for Barb and for Kathy. Nothing I, or anyone else, has to say is all that important, right now. I hope everyone just shuts up and listens, because I don't want to have to duke it out with anyone (though, my dad was The Duke, after all, so...you don't want to pick a fight with me...)